facebook twitter rss vimeo

*
banner

Pageantry pointers
A question of accent

The highly respected professional trumpet player, conductor, adjudicator and teacher Paul Cosh looks at the question of accent in Herbert Howells' classic 'Pageantry'.

Herbert Howells
A portrait of Pageantry: The great man hangs at the Royal Academy of Music 

I am looking forward to the upcoming area contests with some trepidation. ‘Pageantry’ is a classic for bands and it also happens to be a particular favourite of mine. 

In respect of this I would like to mention some thoughts on the nature of the accents used in the score and their interpretation.

I would like to thank Dr. J Clinch, who completed his Doctorate in Historical Musicology and Analysis of the Music of Herbert Howells, for his input as regards confirming my own understanding of the interpretation of the two main accents used.

A question of accent

Those in question are the ^ and the < accents. 

The former (^) is an agogic accent and in one definition is described thus: “stress given to a note through prolonged duration”. 

The latter (<) is more normal and is characterised by a sharper attack and a slight shortening of the note. 

Sacred

Dr. Clinch discussed these accents as used in Howell’s ‘Organ Sonata’ of 1933. He says that on the organ one cannot of course create the same physical accent as on a brass or stringed instrument but is able to differentiate between the two by giving the ^ accented note greater length but not as sustained as Tenuto and by leaving a small space before the < accented note.

Steven Isserlis, the world renowned Cellist, in a tribute to his teacher, Jane Cowan, remarked that; “...one of her main concerns was the art of phrasing: agogic accents-the stretching of time within a strict tempo - were sacred to her”.

In respect of this there are some definitions that suggest an easing of tempo also. This to be treated with care!

Differences

In my orchestral experience of playing Bruckner with one of the finest interpreters of his music, Gunther Wand, we would play the ^ accented note with moderate weight at the front and giving it full value in sound and dynamic, whilst having a tiny space for the articulation. 

The < accented note was played with more front attack and less length, rather as mentioned in relation to the ‘Organ Sonata’. In my, and Dr. Clinch’s, opinion, Howells used these accents with the same intention.

Obvious examples

There are some obvious examples in the first section of the ‘King’s Herald’ where this interpretation makes perfect sense. 

There are examples throughout this opening passage, but the most obvious is the crotchet at the beginning of the 5th bar of Fig. 1 (the chrotchet of the bar of the marked flugel entry)
 
Here it is musically logical to play this note, written with the ^ accent to its full value. 

Pageantry

There are some interpretative questions, not least at Fig.2 where the ^ accent is used in horns and basses and the instruction marc. is used for baritones.  

Here one might suggest longer with some weight on the front of the note in the melodic line and shorter in the baritones.

Pageantry

Conclusions

The use of the Tenuto mark would indicate a more lyrical style. There are some markings that might be considered contradictory but, armed with this background, MDs can come to their own conclusions to overcome these issues. 

One cannot be exact as regards the length of these notes but the knowledge of the musical definition and historical context should be the guide to arriving at a musically satisfactory performance.

Vital

The historical context in which these accents are employed is vital when approaching this marvellous work.

MDs and adjudicators can, of course, make their own judgement in relation to this issue but I would suggest that to ignore the historical context could make for very aggressive and ugly performances.

PS. Fieramente means proudly or boldly.

Paul Cosh

Excerpts published by permission of R. Smith & Co Ltd

Pageantry can be purchased from R. Smith & Co Ltd at: http://www.rsmith.co.uk/ 



Foden's Band - Matt Ford - Lichfield Cathedral

Friday 24 November • 19A The Close, Lichfield WS13 7LD


Enfield Citadel Band -

Saturday 25 November • The Salvation Army. 42 Clarence Road. Southend. SS1 1AN SS1 1AN


Contest: Swiss National Championships

Saturday 25 November • Stravinski Hall, Montreaux. Claude-Nobs 5, 1820 Montreaux, Switzerland 1820


Newstead Brass -

Saturday 25 November • John Godber Centre. Ogle Street. Hucknall. Nottingham NG15 7FQ


Lofthouse Brass Band - Lofthouse Christmas Fair

Saturday 25 November • Lofthouse Methodist Church, Leeds Road, Lofthouse, Wakefield WF3 3NE


Blidworth Welfare Band

November 21 • The Blidworth Welfare band, Midlands Championship section, require a 2nd cornet player to join our friendly but ambitious and hardworking band. A good programme of concerts, recordings and contests will provide an enjoyable challenge.


Blidworth Welfare Band

November 21 • The Blidworth Welfare band, Midlands Championship section, require a principal cornet player to join our friendly but ambitious and hardworking band. . A good programme of concerts, recordings and contests will provide an enjoyable challenge.


The Corsham Band

November 21 • With promotion to the 2nd Section from January 2018 the band are now looking for an experienced Front Row Cornet Player to join our friendly and enthusiastic team.


Martin Heartfield

GGSM, ARCM, PGCE
Conductor, Adjudicator, Educationalist