facebook twitter rss vimeo


Report & Results: 2017 West of England Regional Championships: Second Section

A trio of experienced contest generals led their troops to Cheltenham in the Second Section — led by Bodmin's own version of Monty — John Maines.

Riviera Centre
  John Maines revives the glory days of Bodmin Town to secure a finals berth

A thoroughly engaging Second Section contest eventually saw 'battle experience' count as a trio of musical generals in John Maines, Melvin White and John Berryman took the qualification podium honours on 'Rhapsody in Brass'.

It was a particularly enjoyable musical conflict — although despite its venerable age, Dean Goffin's iconic score still caused immense problems, with adjudicators Paul Norley and Stephen Roberts giving an early indication of what they may have been looking for 24 hours later on 'Pageantry' with their sympathetic remarks.

Intellectually stimulating music

Their twin observations about style, transparency, refinement and elegance — Stephen calling it 'intellectually stimulating music' when speaking to 4BR, ensured that there was also an unanimous consistency about their results — with the qualification performances in particular showing a deep understanding and musical respect for the pace, dynamic and style required in each of the movements.

The best of these came from a delighted Bodmin — a band that has gone through a number of bruising battles over recent years, but which, much like Monty's Eighth Army in North Africa, has been rejuvenated under the leadership of its vastly experienced MD, John Maines.

Huge boost

Speaking later to their tuba player Dave Dobson, 4BR was told that the victory had given the Cornish band another huge boost following recent results and the move back to their band club home.

"This is huge," Dave said. "John has been magnificent and has inspired us to improve at each contest. I think we all felt this one was coming, especially after Butlins this year, but to gain a first Area victory since 1999 when we won the top section was an amazing experience — especially for the younger players."

He added: "Things are really on the up — from our move back to our band club, to seeing so many young players develop through our ranks. It's exciting times once more for Bodmin — and we can't wait to try and win the National title in Cheltenham."


Joining them there was an equally delighted Otterbourne Brass, who continued their recent run of fine form under Melvin White to qualify for the first time since 2012, whilst a thrilled Helston Town also made a long awaited return as they booked their place under John Berryman for the first time since 2008.

"Those three performances did stand out for us," adjudicator Paul Norley later told 4BR. "Although not perfect, each captured the right style and the MDs knew how to pace and control things dynamically. There was some fine solo playing on show too."

Stephen agreed: "It's such intellectually stimulating music to perform. I'm sure every band will have benefitted from playing it. My congratulations go to the top bands — as they really got to stylistic grips with the score."


With both judges also talking about consistency, few people would have disagreed that the title was heading to one of the eventual trio as they displayed admirable control and collective confidence.

However, they were pushed by the likes of Andover Town, who very nearly forced their way into the reckoning as the last band of the day, whilst the remaining top-six places were claimed by colourfully engaging performances from Camborne Junior Contesting and City of Bristol Brass. Behind them came a series of performances that varied a little too much in execution to have pushed further up the results table than they did.

Special mention

A special mention however to St Pinnock directed by John Ward, who were stopped in their tracks not by the advancing forces of Rommel's Afrika Korps, but by the bizarre automatic coloured flashing of the stage lights, which went into 'disco-mode' at the end of their second movement.

After a considerable delay for the stage-hands to sort things out, they bravely completed a performance that will long live in their contest battle memory banks.

Things are really on the up — from our move back to our band club, to seeing so many young players develop through our ranks. It's exciting times once more for Bodmin — and we can't wait to try and win the National title in CheltenhamDave Dobson


Second Section:

Test Piece: 'Rhapsody in Brass' (Dean Goffin)
Adjudicators: Paul Norley and Stephen Roberts

1. Bodmin Town (John Maines)*
2. Otterbourne Brass (Melvin White)*
3. Helston Town (John Berryman)*
4. Andover Town (Steve Large)
5. Camborne Junior Contesting (Alan Pope)
6. City of Bristol Brass (Bryn James)
7. Poole Borough (Martin Portman)
8. Bream Silver (Philip Turner)
9. Downton (Paul Williams)
10. Soundhouse Brass (Lee Clayson)
11. Phoenix Brass (Crewkerne) (Tom Griffin)
12. St. Pinnock (John Ward)
13. Weston Brass (Bryn James)
14. Denmead Brass (Estelle Flood)
15. Shrewton Silver (Michael Dunford)
16. New Forest Brass (Ian Luxford)
17. Ocean Brass (Martin Humphries)

*Top three bands qualify for National Final in Cheltenham

Brian Turner

Turner prize for Brighouse & Rastrick

March 23 • National Champion announces Vice Presidency link with celebrity chef and long time Brighouse fan Brian Turner CBE.


Ten grand reasons for celebration for A4 Brass Quartet

March 23 • The A4 Brass Quartet has claimed the £10,000 first prize at the acclaimed Royal Over-Seas League Chamber Music Competition.


Leonard retires after 25 years of innovative leadership

March 23 • Keith Leonard has announced his retirement as MD after 25 years of service with Derwent Brass.

Band Supplies

Great deals on offer from Band Supplies

March 23 • There are some brilliant ex-demo and second hand deals on at the moment from Band Supplies

Croydon Citadel Band - The International Staff Band of The Salvation Army

Saturday 24 March • The Salvation Army. Booth Rd. Croydon. CR0 1XY CR0 1XY

Black Dyke Band - Newtown (Powys)

Saturday 24 March • Theatre Hafren, Llanidloes Rd, Newtown SY16 4HU

Leyland Band - Annual Patrons' Concert

Sunday 25 March • Chorley Town Hall PR7 1DP

South London Fellowship Band - Royal Tunbridge Wells Songsters

Monday 26 March • The Salvation Army. Royal Tunbridge Wells Corps. Bayhall Road. Tunbridge Wells TN2 4UT

Foden's Band - Sandbach Town Hall - Heritage Launch

Tuesday 27 March • Sandbach Town Hall,High St, Sandbach CW11 1AX

Clifton and Lightcliffe Band

March 24 • Our third section B Band are looking for Cornet and Trombone players. Rehearsals Friday's 7.00 - 8.15pm and Sunday mornings 10.00 - 12.15pm Based at Bailiff Bridge Brighouse. Our Saturday morning training band is also looking for players. All abilities.

Clifton and Lightcliffe Band

March 24 • Second Section band we are looking for a 2nd Trombone and back row cornet. We have a busy concert calendar and a trip to Italy planned for August 2018. Based at Bailiff Bridge Brighouse.

Wakefield Metropolitan Brass Band

March 23 • REPIANO CORNET are you the right person for this seat, we have a sensible mix of concerts and contests with a Germany trip in 2019. Also a 5th place at the yorkshire areas in the 1st section we are looking to build on this for the future.

Alan Duguid

BA (Hons), PGDipMus, PGCE
Conductor, Composer, Adjudicator (ABBA)