2015 British Open Championship — Reflections on Swan Lake

4BR Editor Iwan Fox peers under the surface of the latest British Open test piece by Stephen Roberts.

The man behind it all...

The story behind Swan Lake is a complicated one - and that’s not just the plot either.

It was the first of Tchaikovsky’s (above) three ballets (followed by ‘The Sleeping Beauty’ and ‘The Nutcracker’) and was rather hastily written in 1875, reportedly based on a smaller, earlier work that was later linked to a libretto by Vasily Geltser. 


The ballet somehow survived a rather catastrophic premiere in Moscow in 1877, after the ballerina originally intended to play the central role of Odette was pulled from the production amid allegations that her rather colourful personal life (she was no virginal white swan) was rather at odds with the intended chaste requirements of her character.  

Allied to a ‘stupid’ Germanic storyline, poor choreography, cheap staging and an orchestra not up to the job of playing the score, it was pilloried - although it did survive for six years and 41 performances before finally getting the chop in 1883.

It returned revived, resplendent and partially re-orchestrated in 1895 (two years after the composer’s death) - although the original single suicide ending of the tragic heroine was replaced by a double whammy - as Odette and Siegfried throw themselves into the depths of the icy lake. 


It’s all a bit surreal though: Some early productions included the role of Benno danced by a female dancer en travestie (a hundred years before Matthew Bourne’s celebrated take) with some modern versions now opting for a ‘happy ever after’ finale.
‘Swan Lake’s’ lasting popularity has also spawned a multitude of crackpot ‘adaptations’ - including the ludicrous ’Black Swan’ film and the straight to video ‘Barbie of Swan Lake’ - which can be found in the bargain bucket at any petrol station near you.

However, despite the occasional faux-pas interpretations, it remains a gloriously and unashamedly, romantic’s dream. Audiences love it. 

Stephen Roberts
The man behind the reflections...

With that in mind then, we come to Stephen Roberts’ (above) take on the tale with his ‘Reflections on Swan Lake’ - a test piece full of its own surreal moments, lashings of swashbuckling romanticism cleverly sprinkled with bone-dry wit. 

Bear in mind for instance the title itself: The clever use of the 'on' preposition implying that his version is a deliberately dislocated interpretation of Tchaikovsky’s famous ballet score - and certainly not a direct transcription, realisation or arrangement. 


Just like the opening key signatures, his own description of it being ‘deceptive’ is expertly pitched: Like a slightly distorted mirror, the reflections in question are not perfect imitations.

Even with the ripple effect of the musical image it remains easily identifiable, but on occasions it becomes more opaque, even sardonic in its malleable distortion (the first heard with an early dissonanace before the main cornet solo theme).

Roberts does this deliberately, as he seeks the ‘antagonism’ as he calls it, between the ‘pure’ qualities of melody against technical virtuosity.Some of the link passages have a dark spitefulness about them.

Petit hommage

Even the dedication 'To David Read' is a case in point: 

Any principal cornet with an ounce of historical contesting knowledge will identify the petit hommage of the opening - a mischievous reflection perhaps of ‘A Kensington Concerto’.  

David was unwittingly the first test pilot of Eric Ball’s elegantly simple, yet fearsome test of character.

Quasi tone poem

Thereafter the score unfolds as a quasi tone poem - the themes and leitmotif of which fall with easy familiarity on the ear, the libretto storyline reflecting the four acts of the revised ballet (although the ending takes the triumphant rather than suicidal option).

Much is asked and demanded of the MDs - the composer playing the role of Albert Pierrepoint to a tee with his generous allowance of interpretative rope.  


That said, there has been quite some antagonism towards ‘Reflections’ before a note has been blown in anger. Radical or contemporary it is not - not by a long chalk - but to underestimate its challenges and dismiss it as a retrograde contesting step for the movement as a whole would be a fool’s gamble. 

Stephen Roberts intuitively knows his way around a brass band - especially its weaknesses and foibles - with an expertly attuned sense of clarity of thought. Bands and players don’t like deceptive simplicity - and this piece has it in spades.

Swan Lake
It's all about pin-point precision and elegance...

This is music all about style - the lack of prescriptive accents and detailed musical furniture replaced by inference and adjective: Passion and expressiveness abound - the antithesis of robotic perfection. 

It is symphonic ballet music of the waltz and pas de deux, the bolero and arabesque, czardas and jete - not brake horse power, trickery and laser beams. 


Tempo choices and stylistic nuance are left to discretion: Too much and it is becomes cloying and artificial, too little and it loses character.  MDs must inspire their performers like a latter day Ninette de Valois.

The composer cleverly walks the tightrope between virtuosity and lyricism like a latter day Elvira Madigan (another tragic heroine): His high-wire antics of virtuosity are far enough removed from ground level to make a safety-net outlet redundant, but not as stratospheric or pyrotechnic to become a meaningless display of mindless bravura.


Cornet players (especially the principal) are asked to display a mastery of feminine lyricism - delicate and refined (the second, extended solo at the beginning is a lip-burster of controlled elegance); the euphonium asserts considered masculinity without the need for steroid abuse.  


Interestingly, the bass trombone must quietly go about his business; adding colour and a hint of impending malice (not deafening Odette with a car horn honk in his little solo motifs), whilst the horns and baritones act as secondary, but essential character drivers - busy in their precise ensemble work but still allowed ample opportunity to shine as individuals.  

Swan Lake
Back row cornets as the corps de ballet?

The back row cornets are the corps de ballet (with little glimpses of spotlight - from a filigree repiano to a light footed second cornet), whilst the tubas create a foundation of warmth and depth. The percussion is all about texture - from the delicacy of a light-fingered tambourine to the eerie mystery of a bowed upturned cymbal on a timp.


All that and the wit that emerges at just the right time and place is as dry as an Algonquin Club martini: Hints of Bach and Dvorak mixed into the ether with Jesus Christ Superstar and even Dangermouse.  Any more deliciously mordant and you could imagine Dorothy Parker playing Odette. 


This Swan Lake may be constructed more along the lines of an art-deco outdoor swimming pool than an icy ‘Myth Forest’ reservoir of despair - but it is just a dangerous - especially with its demands on stamina resources. 

In the final quarter, the Tempo poco piu mosso with its ‘Zadock the Priest’ soft tread and the Poco piu moderato excerpt soon after with its ‘Ave Maria’ chording as the cob and pen of Odette and Seigfried finally contemplate their dive into the depths, are simple forms of elegant test piece cruelty on lips already bursting with lactic acid.

Swan neck

It leads seamlessly into a triumphant climax as extended as a swan’s neck - all major chords leading to a cultured penultimate bar draw back (no needless tam-tam) and rousing last chord as the curtain drops and the audience claps their hands raw.

Iwan Fox

Derwent Brass - THIS IS DERWENT 30! Gala Concert

Saturday 9 July • Allestree Woodlands School Theatre, Blenheim Drive, Allestree, Derby DE22 2LW

Lofthouse 2000 Brass Band - Summer Music Sunday - RHS Harlow Carr Gardens

Sunday 10 July • RHS Harlow Carr Gardens. Crag Lane. Harrogate. HG3 1QB HG3 1QB

Thundersley Brass Band - 'Best of British' themed Summer Concert

Sunday 10 July • Richmond Hall,. Richmond Avenue. Benfleet. Essex SS7 5HA

Boarshurst Silver Band - Milnrow Band

Sunday 10 July • Boarshurst Band Club. Greenbridge Lane. Greenfield. Saddleworth OL3 7EW

Otterbourne Brass -

Sunday 10 July • Chandlers Ford Methodist Church so532gj

Crofton Silver Band

July 5 • SOLO CORNET & BACK ROW CORNET. Crofton Silver Band are looking for Solo & Back Row Cornets to add to their line up as the band looks forward to celebrating its 150th Anniversary next year with an exciting mix of concerts and contests.

Crofton Silver Band

July 5 • FLUGEL. Due to work commitments, Crofton Silver Band are looking for a Flugel to add to their line up as the band looks forward to celebrating its 150th Anniversary next year with an exciting mix of concerts and contests.

Enderby Band

July 5 • We are looking for a cornet player (position negotiable). We have a variety of concerts/contests scheduled to continue our journey in the Championship Section. We use social events to create fantastic team working, so you would be joining a fab group.

Derek Renshaw

ABBA Member
Conductor, Band Trainer and Adjudicator.


 © 2022 4barsrest.com Ltd