*
banner

LP review: The Music of Malcolm Arnold

City of London Brass
Conductor: Geoffrey Brand
Harrow Schools' Girls Choir
Soloists: James Watson; Nigel Boddice; Frank Lloyd; Roger Harvey; John Smith
Decca Records: SB 313

Now aged 95, Geoffrey Brand is perhaps the last great polymath to dominate the brass band movement. 

His knowledge and expertise spanned numerous activities – from performer and conductor to arranger, author, publisher, newspaper editor, BBC producer, educator, lecturer, advisor and much, much more.  

His acumen for business was every bit as insightful as his talent for music making. Never afraid to grasp an informed opportunity, it is perhaps only in the last few years that the scope of his influence has really been appreciated. 

That was certainly shown with this ostensibly obscure, yet substantive recording from 1974 that focussed on the music of Malcolm Arnold. 

Different cloth

The pair were well acquainted and had great respect for each other’s talents (which resulted in the 1975 National Final set-work, ‘Fantasy for Brass Band’) - even if artistically as well as temperamentally they were cut from vastly different cloth.

By the mid 70’s the gloss had begun to tarnish on Arnold’s career; his decline hastened by depression and alcohol, a corrosive mix that saw him lose friends and reputation, although both were revived in later years.  

In addition there is a wonderfully lean account of his ‘Quintet’ featuring the emerging student talents of trumpet players James Watson and Nigel Boddice, alongside Frank Lloyd (horn), Roger Harvey (trombone) and John Smith (tuba).  

This project however interested him greatly and he was impressed by the performances of City of London Brass (formed in 1971 by Brand from talented students at various London Colleges) who provided rumbunctious renditions of  ‘Padstow Lifeboat’  and  'Little Suite No.2 for Brass Band’.

In addition there is a wonderfully lean account of his  ‘Quintet’  featuring the emerging student talents of trumpet players James Watson and Nigel Boddice, alongside Frank Lloyd (horn), Roger Harvey (trombone) and John Smith (tuba).  

Song of Freedom

The centrepiece is  ‘Song of Freedom’, commissioned by the National Schools Brass Band Association in 1972. 

It was the result of a nationwide competition built around a series of poems on the theme of ‘Freedom’ from children that Arnold said was of such a high standard that, “…I had great difficulty in not making the work twice as long”.

The seriousness of the writing – Arnold combines dark wit with stimulating forcefulness, melancholy with a positive sense of hope, speaks of a composer who found their narrative both moving and relevant.  

In four movements (‘Prelude’; ‘Hymn’; ‘Intermezzo’; 'Postlude’) it is a touchingly optimistic choral symphony of youthful thoughts and feelings that 50 years later still retains a vibrant, resonant immediacy.  

Aspirations

The seriousness of the writing – Arnold combines dark wit with stimulating forcefulness, melancholy with a positive sense of hope, speaks of a composer who found their narrative both moving and relevant.  

It does not contain one bar of patronising pretentiousness.

Instead, you are left to wonder what happened to the aspirations of the young poets (and each is credited) who wrote the battle cries, “Freedom is our Right”; “We will work for Freedom”; “Freedom will Come”  and  “All People Must be Free”  - sung with such spirit and eagerness by the 200 schoolgirls from seven Harrow schools.  

And what indeed became of their dreams as they now approach the autumnal  ‘Intermezzo’  of their lives half a century on?    

Iwan Fox


Play List:

Side 1:
1. The Padstow Lifeboat, Op.94
2. Little Suite No.2 for Brass Band, Op.93
3. Quintet (for two trumpets, horn, trombone and tuba), Op. 73

Side 2:
1. Song of Freedom, Op.109
i. Prelude
ii. Hymn
iii. Intermezzo
iv. Postlude

Support us for less than a cup of coffee...

4BR wants to ensure that the brass band movement remains vibrant and relevant. We also want to be able to question, challenge and critically examine those who run and play in it, producing high quality journalism that informs as well as entertains our readers.

So if like us you value a strong, independent perspective on the brass band world - then why not consider becoming a supporter and help make our future and that of a burgeoning brass band movement more secure.

So one less cappuccino then?

Support us    



Contest: Whit Friday March Contests

Friday 13 June • Saddleworth & Tameside OL3


Hebden Bridge Brass Band - The 13th annual Hebden Bridge March Contest

Sunday 15 June • St George's Square, Hebden Bridge HX7 8ET


The Portsmouth Grammar School - Concert by The Black Dyke Band

Saturday 28 June • St Marys Church, Fratton, Portsmouth PO15PA PO15PA


Petworth Town Band - Fete in the Park with Petworth Town Band

Saturday 28 June • Grounds of Petworth Park GU28 9LR


Petworth Town Band - Farnham Brass Band and Petworth Town Band

Saturday 28 June • Farnham Carnival


West Wycombe Brass Band

June 11 • We are looking for players. Flugel and Horns. Positions negotiable . Non contesting, easy going, friendly band. Sensible engagement list. Some instruments available. Playing or returning, come along and see for yourself.


Rushden Town Band

June 8 • 2nd Trombone - come and join our amazing trombone section in Rushden Town Band. A varied engagement schedule as well as a tour every other year.


Rushden Town Band

June 8 • B flat bass position for this fun-loving, 1st Section East Midlands band. Varied engagement schedule including a tour every other year.


Derek Renshaw

ABBA Member
Conductor, Band Trainer and Adjudicator.


               

 © 2025 4barsrest.com Ltd