Television review: Our Lives — Battle of the Bands

Monday 27th May
Repeated: Sunday 2nd June
Yeti Media

This was not a programme about brass bands.  It was however one about the people who play in them.

‘Our Lives’ is a documentary series produced by Yeti Media, a Welsh television company which has produced programmes as diverse as ‘The Wedding Guru’ to ‘Sylvia Plath - Life inside the Bell Jar’. ‘Battle of the Bands’ was the first of a new series (this is the third) of eight films commissioned by BBC 1 which celebrate the diversity of UK society.

The narrative line therefore centered on Cory and Tredegar as they prepared for their appearance at the recent Welsh Regional Championships in Wrexham, although the underlying focus was on the people whose lives gain a great deal of musical enjoyment and purpose in being a part of them.

Any level

This then was about excellence, commitment, determination and pride, a sense of belonging and community - in this case Cory tuba player Tim Evans and Tredegar soprano, Ian Roberts; one an engineer with a bit of a chequered past determined to make his young daughter proud of him, the other a headmaster of one of the most demanding pupil referral units in south Wales and therefore juggling youthful responsibilities of a different kind.

It was a story that could have been told about any level of banding in any area of the country - from Cornwall to Scotland and all bandhalls in between. 

Crucially, it didn’t treat those featured with a patronising air of twee disrespect or lazily drawn stereotypes.

Neither though was it meant to explain brass band contesting to the uninitiated.  Why should it?  The audience at the contest painted an easily understandable picture of that particular, insular relevance to the outside world.  

Neither though was it meant to explain brass band contesting to the uninitiated.  Why should it?  The audience at the contest painted an easily understandable picture of that particular, insular relevance to the outside world.  

Sympathetic light

Instead, ‘Battle of the Bands’ shone a sympathetic light on why and how high quality amateur music making is still embedded into local communities - and not just throughout the Welsh valleys. There was humour and a touch of pathos, a pinch of history and plenty of endeavour - but all infused in the prism of a singular pursuit of excellence. 

Cory and Tredegar deserve great credit for their involvement (both also gave a third of their appearance fees to help meet the costs of the Welsh representatives who played in the European Youth Band) - and for proving that brass bands can be a subject for prime time national television entertainment without recourse to a single mention of ‘Brassed Off”.

Hopefully with the four part Sky Arts series to come later this year, it won’t be the last either.   

Iwan Fox

Support us for less than a cup of coffee...

4BR wants to ensure that the brass band movement remains vibrant and relevant. We also want to be able to question, challenge and critically examine those who run and play in it, producing high quality journalism that informs as well as entertains our readers.

So if like us you value a strong, independent perspective on the brass band world - then why not consider becoming a supporter and help make our future and that of a burgeoning brass band movement more secure.

So one less cappuccino then?

Support us    

Foden's Band - Snape Maltings

Saturday 17 August • Snape Maltings, Suffolk IP17 1SP

Black Dyke Band - Macmillan Theatre, Bridgwater

Sunday 18 August • The McMillan Theatre, Bath Road, Bridgwater,Somerset TA6 4PZ

Regent Hall Concerts - Ensemble Sauterelle (french horns and male voices)

Friday 23 August • Charlton House. Charlton Road. London. SE7 8RE SE7 8RE

Sandhurst Silver Band - Music in the Memorial Park

Sunday 25 August • Sandhurst Memorial Park, Yorktown Road, Sandhurst GU47 9DP

Foden's Band - Sandbach

Monday 26 August • The Wheatsheaf, Sandbach, 1 Hightown, Sandbach CW11 1AG

Corby Silver Band

August 17 • We have vacancies for solo cornet, back row cornet and 1st horn. . We are a 3rd section band based in Northamptonshire in the East Midlands. . Rehearsals 8pm - 10pm Monday & Wednesday held in our own band club. We do not charge any subs.

Strata Brass

August 17 • FRONT ROW CORNET/TROMBONE/PERCUSSION in this Yorkshire Championship Band.. MD Jonathan Bates (Solo Horn - Fodens). Rehearsals currently MON/WED - bandroom 5 mins from J35/36 M1, lifts available from Manchester/Leeds/Sheffield/Huddersfield..

Stannington Brass Band

August 17 • A rare opportunity has arisen to join one of Sheffield's leading bands with a vacancy for an EEb TUBA player to complete our bass section. We have a good band room atmosphere and a calendar of interesting concerts and contests

Phil Lawrence

Composer and conductor


 © 2019 4barsrest.com Ltd