Scottish Challenge Shield Summary
| Year | Winners | Conductor | Test piece |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2015 | Johnstone Silver Dances and Arias |
Martyn Ramsay | Own Choice from composer Professor Edward Gregson |
| 2014 | Bon-Accord Silver Of Distant Memories |
Stephen Malcolm | Own Choice |
| 2013 | Newtongrange Silver Corpus Christi |
Lee Skipsey | Own Choice |
| 2012 | Newmilns & Galston Chivalry |
Nigel Boddice MBE | Own Choice |
| 2011 | Kirkintilloch Kelvin Brass | Charles Keenan | Own Choice Test Piece |
| 2010 | Johnstone Silver | Raymond Tennant | Own Choice Test Piece |
| 2009 | Campbeltown Brass Tallis Variations |
Craig Anderson | Own Choice |
