facebook twitter rss vimeo

*
banner

2012 British Open Championship — What the adjudicators said

This is what Derek Broadbent, Stephen Roberts and Steve Sykes wrote in their adjudications for the podium finishers at Symphony Hall.

The 2012 Judges
The 2012 adjudication team of Steve Sykes, Stephen Roberts and Derek Broadbent

More brilliant British Open images from Goldy Solutions can be found at:
http://www.pbase.com/troonly/2012_british_open

Fodens logo1. Foden’s
  

I: Good effective opening, well detailed and tempo works.

E – fine horn ensemble, This drives along – all links nicely done. No lack of verve and the rhythms are heard as you progress. Perc in good form.

G – gets a bit muddy – but you recover – and you make a good close.

II: A tasteful opening – you set the mood. Solo cornet is in fine form – this is beautifully shaped – thank you.

Euphs – in fine form – a pleasure to hear. Horns join the mixture in fine form as does the flugel. Duo well thought out and descends well to X. Trom – excellent from solo. Well supported by all.

Y – a lovely noise here. Sop excels – as do all soloists. This is so nicely put together. Worth listening to! Approach to BB has just the right atmosphere – and onwards you create the mood.

CC – to good effect. DD – BBs to good effect. Bravo Ebs – Bravo again! Euphs don’t disappoint. Thank You! 

III: Good brisk tempo! – well detailed. No lack of conviction. Dynamics and detail are superb! I just listen.

And it was worth listening to!!

Thank you very much – Band, Soloists & Conductor for a magical performance

Derek Broadbent


Driving tempo – and clean! 
 
D - is very articulate.

H – dynamic shapes are convincing

This is played with real commitment.

Super first section.

A little untuneful in 2nd bar of U

A super cornet cornet solo is so well shaped and phrased.

V – has a glorious euphonium. W – solo horn and flugel continue the high standard. X – really beautiful trombone playing here and Y – has a sonorous ensemble.

Z – so lyrical in flugel and soprano. AA – has emotional content and MD shapes so well. CC – is ethereal. DD – Super BBb tubas are as one. EEbs tubas – well phrased.

FF – fantastic euphonium duet!

GG – has drive and purpose. Meticulous playing is very engaging.

Percussion are first rate throughout.

This is playing of great commitment.

VV – has a super final build and leads to a breathless conclusion. Well sorted by MD!

Very enjoyable

Steve Sykes


Good opening, continues with muscular and generally tight articulation. Rhythm is always convincing and weight of sound is rich and full.

U – is secure. Fine solo cornet and lovely euph sounds. Splendid horn and flugel. Excellent solo trombone. Great sop. Marvellous band.

Quality cadenzas.

GG – tight and well judged – good detail

Fabulous – what a performance!

Detail, quality, musicality – it had it all!

Stephen Roberts


Black Dyke2. Black Dyke

I: A fine opening – well detailed – well chosen tempo – perhaps a little more drive would enhance. There is much to commend in his playing.

Dynamics well observed – at times a four semis got lost 8n the six, but there is much to commend. A great close is made.

II: Tasteful horns to open well supported by all. Solo cornet plays with style and grace. A bit sticky in the sixes but you recover to close in fine style. Euph in fine form – well supported by all.

The horn joins the mix as does the flugel. Duo – top form. Solo trombone shows the way – perhaps a bit OTT for my taste. Y – A good ensemble sound. L – reflective – fine sop – take care not to overdo the dynamics here please. Approach to BB – is better. CC – just the mood

DD – BBs safe and secure – nicely shaped. Ebs – bold but in good style. Euphs – emphatic.

III: Brisk tempo. I do hear the opening detail. All details work with good dynamics. There is drive to the music, everything in its place. No lack of commitment in this playing. Exciting stuff!

Fireworks at the end indeed.

A fine performance. This had all the right ingredients of top class playing. Perhaps a little safe in tempos in the opening movement, but little else to worry.

Thank you very much indeed, Band, Soloists and Conductor alike.

Derek Broadbent


Neat, compact and precise to open.

Good dynamic expansions and always with plenty of headroom.

This is highly articulate  playing.

A very impressive first section.

U – just a shade untidy in transition to cornet solo. A very lyrical cornet solo and it flowed so well. V – a vocal euphonium duet. W – solo horn and flugel have a super tone and style.

X – a wonderful trombone solo is so well phrased.

Y – has a sonourous ensemble sound. Great soprano and flugel at Z. Percussion is first rate throughout. CC – is ethereal.

DD – Excellent BBb tubas and clever phrasing! EEb tubas too! Great euphonium duet!

GG – has a great tempo and is thoroughly engaging. All connections are made.

RR – mid band semi quavers are superbly effective!

VV – the final ‘build’ is compelling and leads to a breathless conclusion!

Really nailed it!

Thank You

Steve Sykes


Tempo allows good clarity and band maintains good rhythm and neat ensemble.

Occassional blips on high C#s in cornets but overall a fine 1st movement.

U – not entirely clean. Good solo cornet, but the odd clip is a shame. Good euphs. Fine sounding horns and flugel. Splendid solo trombone – really expressive, if a trifle overdone.

Y – great band sounds with well shaped phrases – dynamics occasionally rise a little too much.

Cadenzas all sound fine and EE sounds excited but controlled rhythmic impetus. Dynamics are impressively displayed!

This was a very fine performance with fine detail, splendid solo playing and well judged tempi.
 
Those minor clips in the slow section just took the winning edge off – otherwise it was near faultless.

Stephen Roberts


Cory3. Cory

I: Good detail and links in the opening sections – this drives on – a well chosen tempo for the musical shapes. H- well linked – a loose moment or two spoils. K – is dramatic – much to commend in this playing. O-P – not your neatest, but you recover. Sop in good form and you close well.

II: Perhaps a shade loud for p to open – then a little uncomfortable moment spoils. Solo cornet – so tasteful – beautifully shaped and so musical – thank you.

Euph – peaceful indeed. W – Solo horn plays with tenderness – flug – joins the mix in good style. Duo – this works so well. Trom – lyrical playing – watch the balance in the close of the duo please.

Y – Gorgeous noises ensure a fine band sound. Sop shines.

Z – Reflective as it should be. Lovely sop lines – so very musical. Thank you –also AA – nothing overdone. Approach to BB – just as it should be and to close. CC – Just the mood. BBs – controlled – nothing overdone. Eb – moody – to good effect. Euphs – bring the close in fine style.

III: I do hear the opening – and this zings along at a brisk tempo. Such good detail is heard – fireworks indeed too – to good effect. There is so much to commend – full of drama – and you head for a close of great impact.

A fine show indeed – with so much to commend. Great detail – great musicality – from top to bottom – just that little moment to open the 2nd movement.

Thanks to Band, Soloists and Conductor for a most enjoyable performance.

Derek Broadbent


Very articulate top open (esp low brass)

Incisive playing and very detailed in dynamic contours.

I note super soprano and bass trombone.

Its all well sorted and a very good first section.

U -  a bit uncertain into 2nd bar.
A really super cornet solo is very lyrical and well phrased.

Y – a real duet – stylish.

W – solo horn and flugel continue this high standard.

X – a seductive trombone solo- lovely legato and well phrased.

Y – a very sonorous tutti sound.

Z – flugel and soprano play with a wonderful style

CC – is ethereal. DD – secure and shaped tuba cadenzas

FF – euphoniums are impressive

GG – has pace and has great intensity.

HH onwards to II – not all high cornet downbeat quavers are in the slot!
bar 339 is very effective here

OO – good dynamic shapes 

TT – incisive + VV – the final ‘build’ is terrific!

Good show! – very well sorted

Thank You

Steve Sykes


Opening is secure and rhythmic cells mainly well executed with plenty of vivacity and musicality. Sop is outstanding.

U – not quite secure. Solo cornet plays nicely with good sense of style. Euphs sing well together in spite of small clip.

Horn and flugel sound fine and there is a pleasing sense of musical flow. Solo trombone is well projected and full band sound leads to a good sense of climax.

Z – very fine sop plying – bravo!

Atmospheric close is nicely judged. Tuba cadenzas well shaped and euphs flow nicely into GG which has good detail. There is plenty of merit here – it has punch and excitement, but is controlled.

A very fine performance, with plenty of life and punch. 

The slow movement flowed beautifully and the whole piece hung together most convincingly. Bravo!

Stephen Roberts



Tredegar Town Band - Mussorgsky meets Mozart

Wednesday 20 June • ROYAL BIRMINGHAM CONSERVATOIRE, Birmingham City University, 200 Jennens Rd, Birmingham. B4 7XR


Black Dyke Band - Halifax Choral Society

Saturday 23 June • Victoria Theatre, 2 Fountain St, Halifax HX1 1BP


The Marple Band - The Marple Band presents Music from Musicals

Saturday 23 June • Stockport Grammar School. Buxton Road. Stockport SK2 7AF


Elland Silver Band - Elland Silver Band

Saturday 23 June • Blackley Blackley Church Prospect View Elland HX5 0TD


York Railway Institute Band - Dan Thomas - Euphonium

Saturday 23 June • Central Methodist Church. St Saviourgate. York. YO1 8NQ YO1 8NQ


Torbay Brass Band

June 19 • Torbay Brass Band is looking for trombone and cornet players to join their current set up. We are a friendly hard working group who really would welcome such players into our fold. So if you are looking to join a band or returning to playing....?


Crewe Brass

June 19 • Crewe Brass currently have vacancies for Eb and BBb Bass, Baritone, and Cornet. We are a friendly, social first section band with a good mix of concerts and contests, and rehearse on Monday and Friday evenings in Shavington, Crewe.


Hade Edge Band

June 19 • An opportunity has arisen at Hade Edge Band for an Eb bass player to join our very friendly First Section Band. We rehearse on a Tuesday and Thursday evenings in Hade Edge Band Room, Greave Road, Hade Edge from 8pm to 10pm


John Ward


Conductor, Adjudicator