Report & Result: 2015 Grand Shield

Rothwell Temperance conquers Arabian Nights to head to Symphony Hall and the British Open with Woodfalls joining them in Birmingham.

Rothwell Win

You suspect the only thing the players and supporters of Rothwell Temperance didn’t do in Blackpool on Saturday night was to celebrate their Grand Shield victory in quite the way their historic contesting name may have suggested.

No surprise really after MD Dave Roberts led the Yorkshire band to a fine victory with a rendition of ‘Arabian Nights’ described by the composer Stephen Roberts in his written adjudication remarks as, ‘…a fantastic performance, scintillatingly shaped and virtuosically delivered’, whilst fellow judge Rob Wiffen added that it was ‘…a very strong performance throughout’, ‘well shaped by the conductor’.

Symphony Hall return

Victory — the band’s second since 2009, will see them return to the British Open for the first time since 2012 where they can now look forward to tackling another Stephen Roberts work, ‘Reflections on Swan Lake’.

They will be joined at Symphony Hall, by Woodfalls, after they claimed their first Open appearance in almost 30 years under the baton of Dr Robert Childs, helped in no small measure by the stunning ‘Best Soloist’ contribution of star trombonist Brett Baker.

Hard to escape

Both bands will have celebrated long into the Blackpool night after the contest once again lived up to its reputation as being the most difficult of all to escape from.

The fancied Scottish challenger Whitburn was left to rue the cruelest of contesting fates as they finished third for the second year in a row under the direction of Prof Nicholas Childs, whilst Midlands Area champion Virtuosi GUS couldn’t quite make an immediate return to Birmingham as they ended fourth.

Reg Vardy will hope to make it third time lucky in 2016 after they could only claim fifth, with Marsden showing that they are getting closer to a future British Open appearance with their sixth placed finish.

Behind them came a host of bands left to contemplate booking into Golden Mile Bed & Breakfast for another year, with Northop, Camborne, Hepworth and EYMS filling the remaining top 10 places ahead of the midfield finishers of Tongwynlais, Mount Charles, Pemberton, Burry Port, Wingates and Aldbourne.

Bursting with pride

No such worries for the Rothwell Band Manager though, and after such a closely fought battle to reclaim their prized British Open status, no wonder their usually reserved MD Dave Roberts was bursting with emotion as he held the Grand Shield aloft for the second time in six years.

“Even though we were drawn early on the day (number 4), I told my players I knew we could win the contest,” he said.

“As we have shown over the years, we are a very good band — and after the disappointment of just missing out on qualification for the National Finals I was determined the same thing wouldn’t happen here.”

He added: “I couldn’t have asked for anything more from every single player. We have played well this year but this was at a different level altogether. I came off stage knowing we couldn’t have done anything better — and I’m so pleased that such a superb performance was rewarded by the judges in this way.”

Secret of success

David also revealed that part of the secret to the success lay in retelling the tale of ‘Scheherazade’ in the same way he did when leading Kirkintilloch to seventh place at the British Open on the piece in 2013.

“I always refer back to adjudicator’s notes and taking the educated guess that Stephen and Rob would be back in the box I made sure I looked at them again. They really enjoyed what I did then with tempos, dynamics and bringing out the character in the music — so I thought there was no real need to try and do something different. I’m glad I guessed right!”

Musical character

He certainly did, with the judges later telling 4BR that in what was a close battle at the top end of the results table, Rothwell’s ability to bring out the musical character of the richly coloured score was the key to their ‘clear victory’.

Stephen Roberts had earlier told the audience waiting for the results in the Winter Gardens that both he and Rob Wiffen had been ‘really impressed’ by the standard of the 20 competitors, and especially by the quality of the solo playing.

Boiled down

The destination of the title he said had ‘boiled down to bringing out good musical characterisation from the score’, as well as overcoming the ‘deliberately difficult technical challenges’ whilst still maintaining stamina, especially in the quiet section towards the end of the piece.

That was certainly their opinion of the winners, who produced the stand out marker in a high quality first half of the contest to repel the strong challenge of later rivals and claim the title off the earliest draw number since 1998.

Woodfalls stun

With Whitburn looking set to end their five year Blackpool stay under the baton of Prof Nicholas Childs with a supremely confident account at the midway point, the Symphony Hall qualification places looked to be settled until Woodfalls produced a stunning rendition as the penultimate contender to deny them.

With the West of England band boosted by recent signings, Dr Robert Childs detailed interpretation brought he best out of his hard working ensemble, led by Brett Baker and principal cornet Jan Boler, as they pipped their Scottish rivals to secure their first British Open appearance since 1986.


At the other end of the results table there was to be further disappointment for Scotland as Kingdom Brass fell through the relegation trap door to the Senior Cup, joined by Thoresby Colliery, Redbridge and Unite the Union (City of Sheffield).

Back at British Open

However, for one of the hardest working, non-sponsored community based top flight bands in the UK, there was only celebrations and a few alcoholic beverages to enjoy as Rothwell Temperance once again claimed their place back at Symphony Hall.

And as David Roberts added before being swamped by celebrating supporters: “That’s what makes this victory all the more special.

We all worked our socks off this win — and I’ll still come back to our next rehearsal to see all our own players sat there determined to make a mark at the British Open.”

We have played well this year but this was at a different level altogether. I came off stage knowing we couldn’t have done anything better — and I’m so pleased that such a superb performance was rewarded by the judges in this wayMD, David Roberts


The Grand Shield:
Opera House
Test Piece: Arabian Nights — Fantasy on Rimsky Korsakov’s Scheherazade for Brass Band (Stephen Roberts)

Adjudicators: Stephen Roberts & Rob Wiffen

1. Rothwell Temperance (David Roberts)*
2. Woodfalls (Dr Robert Childs)*
3. Whitburn (Prof. Nicholas Childs)
4. Virtuosi GUS (Adam Cooke)
5. Reg Vardy (Russell Gray)
6. Marsden Silver Prize (Glyn Williams)
7. Northop Silver (Thomas Wyss)
8. Camborne Town (John Berryman)
9. Hepworth (Mark Peacock)
10. East Yorkshire Motor Services (Alan Morrison)
11. Tongwynlais Temperance (Christopher Bond)
12. Mount Charles (David Stowell)
13. Pemberton Old Wigan DW (Kevin Gibbs)
14. Burry Port Town (Nigel Seaman)
15. Wingates (Paul Andrews)
16. Aldbourne (Jonathan Pippen)
17. Unite the Union (City of Sheffield) (David Hirst)**
18. Redbridge (Alan Duguid)**
19. Thoresby Colliery (Brian Grant)**
20. Kingdom Brass (Eoin Tonner)**

Best Instrumentalist: Brett Baker, (trombone) — Woodfalls

*Promoted to British Open
**Relegated to Senior Cup

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    


Welsh invited to opening of the box...

April 22 • Brass Bands Wales has linked up with the Association of Brass Band Adjudicators for an evening workshop looking at all aspects of the judging process.

Mark Wilkinson

4BR Thursday Interview with Mark Wilkinson

April 22 • 4BR talks to Foden's Band Manager Mark Wilkinson to find out more about the worldwide response to their forthcoming online Whit Friday contest weekend and their plans to safeguard their musical future and recall their past.


4BR Wednesday Interview with Patrick Ottiger

April 21 • 4BR catches up with the Yamaha professional trumpet star and inspirational conductor of the BML Talents Band in Switzerland to find out more about musical life, Jerusalema dance moves and contesting promotion...


Swiss soloists respond in number

April 21 • Over 350 players and 32 quartets entered the online Swiss Solo and Quartet Championships this year — with the finals set to take place in Berne in May.

Contest: 100thSpring Festival

Saturday 8 May • 97 Church St, Blackpool, FY1 1HL

Contest: 168th British Open

Saturday 11 September • Symphony Hall, Broad Street, Birmingham. B1 2EA

Contest: Lower Section National Finals

Saturday 18 September • The Centaur, Cheltenham Race Course, Prestbury, Cheltenham GL40 4SH

Contest: Lower Section National Finals

Sunday 19 September • The Centaur, Cheltenham Racecourse, Prestbury, Cheltenham, GL40 4SH

Contest: National Brass Band Championship of Great Britain

Saturday 2 October • Kensington Gore, South Kensington, London SW7 2AP

Chinnor Silver

April 19 • With rehearsals starting soon in line with government guidelines we are looking to strengthen BACKROW CORNETS &PERCUSSION TEAM concerts and contests planned.we rehearse on wednesdays in our own bandroom check out our lockdown performances and come join us

Chadderton Band

April 17 • Chadderton Band is a friendly non-contesting band playing at various events throughout the year. We are looking for players of all ages and abilities on all sections of the band particularly on Euph Drums and Horn. Come along for a blow most welcome.

Oxford Cherwell Brass

April 14 • Returning to the band room in May we have vacancies for second and third cornets. Rehearsals are Wednesday evenings 8-10pm at Edward Feild School, Kidlington. The band has engagements and contests lined up from late summer onwards.

Stuart Black

BA (Hons) Music
Conductor, Teacher, Flugel soloist


 © 2021 4barsrest.com Ltd