facebook twitter rss vimeo


Scots fight against pay to play decisions in education

Passionate campaigns are being fought against the latest tranch of local authority decisions to impose fees for instrumental tuition in schools in Scotland.

  The campaign hopes to stop the pay and play decisions that many local authorities are now imposing

An impassioned campaign to try and stop yet another of Scotland's 32 Local Authorities imposing fees for peripatetic music instrument tuition is gaining widespread support.


It follows the recent decision of South Ayrshire Council to set fees of up to £300 per year for a family with two children who wish to play a musical instrument as part of their educational development, and the doubling of fees for children in Clackmannanshire that has seen them rise to £560 per year.

On the 17th of April, West Lothian Council — an authority that within its borders has some of the top brass bands in Scotland as well as a long history of support to one of the finest youth bands in the UK, will consider voting on making significant cuts to the peripatetic music services in its schools.

UN Convention

Such has been the outcry that Nick Hobbs, the Head of Advice and Investigations of the Office of the Children and Young People's Commissioner Scotland has written to the Chair of West Lothian Council's Education Executive to criticise their plans to cut school strings and percussion, citing the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child.

A focused part of the ongoing campaign is being led by Dalmellington trombonist Ralph Riddiough, who told 4BR that the spate of recent decisions could have a generational impact on children's future.

"Although people may think this only relates to a small part of Scotland, the reality is that these short sighted decisions have fast become the norm.

The Scottish Government is responsible for education, but the cost of Instrumental Music Services in each of the 32 local authorities is not ring fenced.

Everyone appreciates that budgets are under immense strain, but cutting these services and imposing fees on families, many of whom are already making difficult education decisions is so short sighted and ultimately destructive.

It's quickly becoming a 'luxury' service for those who can afford to pay for it."

Investment pays dividends

He added: "I'm trying to make the argument that investing in instrumental tuition pays rich dividends, many times over the initial cost of provision and in so many different ways. The reality is that it's a forward thinking, smart, thing to do."

4BR understands that the recent South Ayrshire Council decision meant that its Instrumental Music Service tuition (with an instrument provided) is now no longer free to all pupils.

Only those children in receipt of free school meals do not now pay, whilst a family with one child has to find £200 per year. A second child adds another £100, although there is no cost for further family members.

I'm trying to make the argument that investing in instrumental tuition pays rich dividends, many times over the initial cost of provision and in so many different ways. The reality is that it's a forward thinking, smart, thing to doRalph Riddiough

Means testing stigma

"Although there is some provision to help, there is also a stigma of 'means testing' about this," Ralph Riddiough added.

"Peripatetic music provision should be available and enjoyed by all children regardless of their family circumstances. The long term effect of these short sighted decisions will impact on generations to come."

Not only has support for the reversal of the Ayrshire decision and to stop the proposed West Lothian decision come from hundreds of families that will be directly affected, it has also seen many of the UK's most celebrated musicians join in to, with the likes of trombone star Ian Bousfield, composer James MacMillan and the legendary Denis Wick signing the recent Ayrshire petition.

Find out more

To find out more about the campaign go to:



David Childs

Atlantic crossing and global outreach for Childs

April 23 • David Childs accepts new academic role in the USA as well as being featured in this year's Proms Concerts in the UK.


Report & Result: 2018 Band Cymru Youth competition

April 23 • Band Jazz Ysgol Tryfan , a remarkable jazz ensemble from a single secondary school in North Wales has won the televised Band Ieuenctid Cymru competition for youth bands

Warwick Arts Centre

Result: 2018 National Youth Championships of Great Britain: Championship Section

April 22 • Youth Brass 2000 retains its Championship Section National crown in Warwickshire.

Wardle Junior Blast

Result: 2018 National Youth Championships of Great Britain: Beginners Section

April 22 • It's a winning 'Blast' from Wardle as they retain the Beginners Section title in Warwick.

Lofthouse Brass Band - Mayor's Annual Charity Concert

Monday 23 April • Ossett Town Hall, Market Place, Ossett WF5 8BE WF5 8BE

Regent Hall Concerts - Clarendon Brass Ensemble

Friday 27 April • Charlton House. Charlton Road. London. SE7 8RE SE7 8RE

Egremont Junior Band - Egremont Town Band and Workington Town Band

Friday 27 April • Workington CA14 3AW

Wotton and District Silver Band - Tom Hutchinson

Saturday 28 April • St Mary's Church, Wotton Under Edge, Gloucestershire GL12 7LS

Black Dyke Band - Lincoln Cathedral

Saturday 28 April • Minster Yard, Lincoln LN2 1PX

Hathern Band

April 23 • Hathern Band are looking for a PRINCIPAL EUPHONIUM to join their Championship Section Band. This position has become vacant because the present player wishes to retire. We are looking for a committed player to fill this key seat. www.hathernband.co.uk.

Lofthouse Brass Band

April 23 • Lofthouse Brass Band require a DRUMMER to complete their line up. We are a friendly 3rd section band who rehearse on Thursday evenings 7.30pm - 9pm and Saturday mornings 10am - 12noon at Outwood WMC.

Lindley Band

April 22 • TUTTI CORNET required to join friendly team who enjoy a sensible balance of contests and high quality engagements under the direction of our new MD Rob Westacott. We rehearse Monday and Wednesday evenings in our own bandroom just 1 mile from M62 Jcn 24.

David Hirst

MA, B.Ed (Hons), LTCL
Conductor, adjudicator and arranger