*
banner

Report & Result: 2024 Band Supplies Scottish Challenge Contest

Kirkintilloch retains the Challenge honours in Perth.

  Kirkintilloch celebrate their victory in Perth

The Kirkintilloch Band retained their hold on the Band Supplies Challenge Shield with a finely judged performance of Edward Gregson's imposing 'Of Men and Mountains' in Perth.

It rounded off a solid contesting year for Hedley Benson's band as they secured a domestic 'double' after winning the First Section Scottish Championship at this venue in March.

High quality

The £300 first prize was also enhanced by the award of the 'Best Horn Section' as they produced the high-quality marker from the early number 6 draw for judges Alan Widdop and Brett Baker to compare against 20 determined rivals.

Reflecting on their success on their Facebook page the band stated: "We are absolutely delighted to have retained the title for the second year in a row. We are also delighted that our fabulous horn section also retained their prize as well. The band played superbly.

Thank you to the Scottish Brass Band Association for their efforts in putting on the contest!"

Enjoyed

Speaking about the overall standard, Alan Widdop said it had been "superb" and that he had "enjoyed every minute of it" alongside colleague Brett Baker.

He praised the "tremendous" soloists in every band, with a special mention to the "superb" trombone lead in 'The Year of the Dragon' (later revealed as Symone Kelly Hutchison of Clackmannan District in winning the 4BR 'Best Soloist' award).

And whilst he jokingly said that whilst no band had picked a work that was "unplayable"to result in a "car crash", a "few had run off the road", although he was quick to point out the selections made by all bands had been well made in that they could "play them very well".

He also offered advice on the approach needed to successfully "portrait" the test-piece choices, from balance to quality of sound.

Close battle

It proved to be a close battle for the title spoils. Runner-up Newmilns & Galston ended just a point behind, as they once again displayed fine form at the event under MD Alan Friel (having come fourth and third in recent years) with a classy rendition of 'English Heritage' — aided by the 'Best Principal Cornet' playing of Dougie Cameron.

The final podium place was claimed by Bo'ness & Carriden with their purposeful rendition of 'Tallis Variations', led by Chris Bradley, whilst the remaining top-six places went to Clackmannan District (taking the 'Best Second Section Band' honours), ahead of St David's Brass and Granite City Brass.

A delighted Clackmannan later took to their Facebook page to add their congratulations to their award-winning trombonist. "Wowzer! Symone Kelly Hutchison — You tamed the Dragon!"

Section awards

Other section awards went to Perthshire Brass, thanks to their vibrant account of 'Hollywood' by Goff Richards to take the Third Section prize, with Buckhaven & Methil securing the Fourth Section award for a second successive year with their rendition of 'Music for Jock Tamson'.

Once again the Scottish Brass Band Association ran a fine event at Perth Concert Hall, with a vibrant atmosphere and communal support for all the competing bands.

Amazing day

SBBA President Carrie Boax thanked everyone for what she said "was an amazing day" — the first of what will be three at the Scottish Festival of Brass (the Scottish Open and Youth Championships taking place on the weekend of Saturday 23rd and Sunday 24th November).

Carrie also thanked stalwart SBBA member Peter Fraser for his organisational support, whilst Ronnie Tennant from sponsor Band Supplies also added his thanks to 'Wee Peter' who he has been valued friend for over 50 years, the bands, SBBA and its Young Ambassadors.

With thanks to Nigel Martin (SBBA)

We are absolutely delighted to have retained the title for the second year in a rowKirkintilloch Band

Result:

Adjudicators: Brett Baker; Alan Widdop

1. Kirkintilloch (Hedley Benson): 191
2. Newmilns & Galston (Alan Friel): 190
3. Bo'ness & Carriden (Chris Bradley): 188
4. Clackmannan District (Paul Drury): 186
5. St David's Brass (John A Dickson): 185
6. Granite City Brass (Bruce Wallace): 184
7. Dunaskin Doon (Ralph Brill): 183
8. Johnstone Band (Joshua Parkhill): 182
9. Shotts St Patrick's (Andy Shaw): 181
10. Campbeltown (Andrew McMillan): 180
11. Regent Brass (Alan Duguid): 179
12. Perthshire Brass (Willie McMullan): 178
13. Irvine & Dreghorn (Helen Douthwaite Teasdale): 177
14. North Lakes Brass (Gareth Sykes): 176
15. Dysart Colliery Silver (Robert Fraser): 175
16. Buckhaven & Methil Miners (Steven Craig): 174
17. Kilmarnock Concert Band (Rebecca Wilson Paterson): 173
18. Dundee Instrumental (Bob McDonald): 172
19. Dunfermline City Brass (Stephen Duncan): 171
20. Forfar Instrumental (Donald Innes): 170
21. Turriff Silver (Matt Bailey): 169


Best Horn Section: Kirkintilloch Band
Best Principal Cornet: Newmilns & Galston
Best Soloist: Solo Trombone (Clackmannan & District)

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    


Besson

Besson ready with early Christmas offers

November 29 • If you are at the Swiss or Swedish Nationals, the Scottish Open or just off to do some earlier Christmas musical shopping, then put Besson on Santa's list — for some great deals.


swiss

Swiss connections add to Lucerne coverage

November 27 • 4BR will be linking up with their Swiss friends at BRASS BAND NEWS to provide extra insight and opinions about the performances in Lucerne this weekend.


Philip Sparke

Sparke ignites demand for 2026 RNCM International Brass Band Festival

November 27 • There has already been an eager snap up of tickets for the showcase event at the RNCM in Manchester in January — led by a 75th birthday celebration of composer Philip Sparke.


Perth

Domestic and cross border challengers head to Perth

November 27 • The bands are putting their final touches to their preparations for the Scottish Open and Scottish Youth Championships this weekend in Perth.


Hathersage Band - Hathersage Village Christmas Concert

Saturday 29 November • Hathersage Methodist Church, Main Road, Hathersage S32 1BB S32 1BB


Barnsley Brass - A Night At The Movies

Saturday 29 November • Worsbrough Miners Welfare. Park Road. Worsbrough Bridge. Barnsley S70 5LJ


Dobcross Silver Band - Unite the Union Band

Sunday 30 November • Dobcross Band Club. Platt Lane. Dobcross . Saddleworth. Oldham OL3 5AD


Garforth Brass - Strawberry Fields Primary School

Friday 5 December • Garforth Methodist Church,. Church Lane,. Garforth,. Leeds LS25 1NW


Petworth Town Band - Petworth Town Band Christmas Event

Saturday 6 December • Petworth Town Centre GU28 OAD


Hathersage Band

November 27 • BACK ROW CORNET. Hathersage Brass Band is a thriving, non-contesting community band. We enjoy our music making, play a wide variety of music and have a good gig schedule. Are you the right person to join our happy band?


wantage silver band

November 27 • 4th section national finalists Wantage Academy are looking for a Bb bass and 2nd cornet to complete their team. A friendly, welcoming band who rehearse Wed 7-8:30pm and Sat 10am-12 under MD Gavin Clemons.


Summerbridge & Dacre Silver Band

November 25 • 2nd or 3rd cornet required to boost our back row. We are a non contesting band, but carry out numerous events across North Yorkshire. We will be doing a joint concert with Carlton Main next year.


Jack Capstaff

Bmus (Hons)
Conductor | Composer


               

 © 2025 4barsrest.com Ltd