facebook twitter rss vimeo shop label support us


Report & Result: 2019 Butlins Mineworkers Championships: Championship Section

4BR Editor Iwan Fox reports on Desford's success in regaining the Mineworkers Championship with a consistent display of high class test-piece and entertainment talents in Skegness.

  All smiles and cheers for Desford Colliery as they are crowned 2019 Butlins Mineworkers Champion

Desford's mercurial contesting reputation may well be consigned to history if their victory, built on high-class consistency at the Butlins Mineworkers Championship, becomes the ingrained ethos behind their future competitive intent.

If so, such was the stamp of quality about their performances in both the test-piece and entertainment disciplines at the Skegness Resort that the rest of 2019 and beyond could well be marked by repeated podium success.

Class apart

Over the two days they were a class apart from their rivals; £11,000 of prize-money cash secured by a classy rendition of 'Carnival' overture that sparkled with colour and energy, and an entertainment set that was a display case of expertly curated borrowed invention.

And whilst there have been a few false dawns of optimism with Desford over the years, the arrival of Michael Fowles has brought an obvious level of thoroughness to their contest preparations which has allowed a group of experienced top-flight performers to shine.

On this impressive evidence it looks set to continue.

The Dvorak overture set out their stall; the florid technicalities played with clarity and brilliance (aided by the excellent 'Best Soloist' Gary Wyatt) to supplement the controlled infusion of drama, whilst the occasional mishap didn't leave a permanent tarnish mark on the MD's cultured musical picture.

The following day saw them tighten their vice-like grip on the ornate heft of the Warwick Vase trophy.

The familiar strains of 'Malaquena' settled any potential nerves before a crafty touch of unfamiliar inventiveness (to the packed audience at least) saw Nick Hudson on sublime 'Starfish' form leading into an evocative 'Karma Naan' Indian detour, a touch of sophisticated Pat Metheny jazz and a dollop of evangelical religious zeal to close.

The substantial winning margin did not flatter them.

Spirited Friary

Behind Desford came well-beaten rivals — although ones that were led by a brilliantly spirited Friary Brass Band (the Guildford name has now been dropped), led by Chris King.

They responded to a mediocre rendition of 'Benvenuto Cellini' by producing an inspired 'Friary Fairytale' set that deservedly claimed the top spot (and the £1000 bonus) in the 'Most Entertaining' element and came third in music quality.

A mix of pantomime and pathos, with a steak of clever humour to go with the musical substance (with just the right pinch of adult double-entendre to go with items from The Beatles, Elton John and Whitney Houston) it was aimed to put a big cheesy smile on the faces of listeners and judges alike (Alan Morrison and Mike Kilroy calling it 'fantastic entertainment' and even 'Genius').

It did just that — with gorgonzola topping to spare.

A trombone tale inspired by the search for true love, and written in the best 'The play what I wrote' Ernie Wise mode by the MD, it was played with admirable 'straightness' by the leading lady Isobel Daws (was gave a splendid rendition of 'Thoughts of Love' to win the 'Best Soloist' prize and £300), aided by comic cameos by the players (especially the coiffured tuba).


This was thoroughly engaging fayre perfectly pitched to mirror the Butlins ethos of entertainment. As a result it gained just reward from both sets of judges (Alan Fernie and Brian Rostron judged the music on both days), enabling Friary to pip Woodfalls and grab £6,000 in the process.

They in turn were perhaps a touch unlucky in the overall scheme of things, as Dr Robert Childs balanced a cultured 'Carnival' overture on the Saturday with an entertainment set focused with a more vintage inspiration the following day.

Maybe their 'comedy' take on 'Cops & Robbers' showed its age like an old lag out on day release from Wormwood Scrubs, but elsewhere it was impressive stuff — especially a touching 'Little Prayer', the sparkling 'Battleground' duet featuring Jan Boler and Fabian Bloch and the robust 'Triumph' finisher.

Not vintage

No title triumph and only a few signs of vintage Flowers over the two days (although they gave a splendid Friday evening concert), as the renewed partnership with Paul Holland saw the defending champion stutter to a disappointing fourth place.

Their hard earned reputation for high class consistency will surely return as the season unfolds, but they would have had little cause for complaint after an undistinguished account of 'Benvenuto Cellini' left them with too much ground to make up on their rivals.

Their Brass in Concert 'Freedom' set had familiar substance and purpose, but that damage had been done on the Berlioz, whilst some unforced errors and mishaps on the Sunday sealed their fate.

Meanwhile, the 2019 rebuilding process will surely gain greater substance with Virtuosi GUS, after Chris Jeans carefully managed his youthful resources to end fifth. A workmanlike 'Carnival' overture was added to with a considered entertainment set, topped by a quite sublime piece of cornet artistry by James Fountain.


Redbridge also showed glimpses of their potential under Richard Ward, although they never quite had 'Carnival' under control on the Saturday and unfortunately, due to a breakdown in communications with the Butlins tech team, were unable to exert much control over the multi-media graphics to start their entertainment set the following day.

The well thought out Moon Landing anniversary initially lost its trajectory much like Apollo 13, and although it splashed down successfully to close, it was not without its 'make do and mend' approach to some of the items.

For Haverhill, the Skegness experience this year was a mixture of highs and lows — with a purposeful and admirably directed 'Carnival' overture (that came third) under Paul Filby, counterbalanced by a hit and miss 'Greek' entertainment set (although they were also unfortunate that their multi-media presentation package couldn't be utilised by the Butlins technicians).

However, it did show that an improving top-flight band now has a firm grip on the coattails of their Stevenage rivals.

There has been an ongoing debate in recent years that despite Butlins substantial investment in prize money for this particular contest (close on £21,000), it continues to fail to attract the highest ranked bands in the UK.

That may well be for a variety of differing reasons, although as Stan Lippeatt's excellent test-piece choices and Desford's renewed competitive vigour showed, reputations at Skegness count for little: It will always be hard graft and musical inspiration that wins the big bucks.

Iwan Fox

Over the two days they were a class apart from their rivals; £11,000 secured by a classy rendition of 'Carnival' overture that sparkled with colour and energy, and an entertainment set that was a display case of expertly curated borrowed invention4BR


Championship Section:

Alan Fernie & Brian Rostron (Test Piece)
Alan Fernie & Brian Rostron (Entertainment Music)
Mike Kilroy & Alan Morrison (Entertainment)

(Test Piece + Entertainment (music) + Entertainment*) = Total
*takes precedence

1. Desford Colliery (LMTF) (Michael Fowles): 1/1/2 = 4
2. Friary Brass Band (Chris King): 6/3/1* = 10
3. Woodfalls (Dr Robert Childs): 2/4/4* = 10
4. Flowers (Paul Holland): 7/2/3 = 12
5. Virtuosi GUS (Chris Jeans): 5/5/5 = 15
6. Redbridge Brass (Richard Ward): 4/6/6 = 16
7. Haverhill Silver (Paul Filby): 3/7/7 = 17

Highest Placed Mining Band: Desford Colliery (LMTF)
Most Entertaining Band: Friary Brass
Geoff Dove Soloist Award: Isobel Daws (trombone) — Friary Brass
Test Piece Solo Award: Gary Wyatt (cornet) — Desford Colliery (LMTF)

Support us for less than a cup of coffee...

4BR wants to ensure that the brass band movement remains vibrant and relevant. We also want to be able to question, challenge and critically examine those who run and play in it, producing high quality journalism that informs as well as entertains our readers.

So if like us you value a strong, independent perspective on the brass band world - then why not consider becoming a supporter and help make our future and that of a burgeoning brass band movement more secure.

So one less cappuccino then?

Support us    


2019 European Composer finalists announced

January 18 • A Belgian and two English writers will have their works performed in the final of the seventh European Composer Competition in Montreux in April.


New youth venture spearheads participation, inspiration and enjoyment

January 18 • An exciting new initiative spearheaded by Sam Harrison of Elland Youth Band aims to bring a different approach to showcasing youth band musical talent.

Special offer

January Special Offers from Band Supplies

January 18 • There are some fantastic special offers on at Band Supplies at the moment — so why not save some money and get in touch.


Fairey add to their line-up with new signings

January 18 • Fairey look back and forward with their new signings ahead of their high profile RNCM Brass Band Festival appearance.

Black Dyke Band - Symphony Hall

Sunday 20 January • Broad Street, Birmingham B1 2EA

Grimethorpe Colliery Band - Grimsby Auditorium

Sunday 20 January • Grimsby Auditorium . Grimsby Auditorium, . Cromwell Rd, . Grimsby, . North East Lincolnshire . DN31 2BH DN31 2BH

Foden's Band - RNCM Brass Band Festival

Friday 25 January • 124 Oxford Rd, Manchester M13 9RD

Regent Hall Concerts - Canon Brass (brass quintet) from the Royal College

Friday 25 January • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street Opp. RESERVED. London . W1C 2DJ

Black Dyke Band - International Staff Band of Salvation Army - RNCM

Saturday 26 January • Royal Northern College of Music, 124 Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9RD

Nailsworth Silver band

January 18 • Vacancies have arisen for a front row CORNET and EB BASS to complete our area line up. We rehearse on Mondays in our own bandroom. Friendly well attended rehearsals. It's our centenary year so CD, concert with Tom Hutchinson and trip to France booked.

Chinnor Silver

January 17 • We are looking for CORNETS AND Bb BASS to complete our area line up. we rehearse on wednesdays in our own bandroom which are well attended and have a good atmosphere.. Realistic book of concerts and contests

Drighlington Band

January 17 • We are keen to fill our final remaining vacancies prior to the Yorkshire Regional Contest & are looking to recruit Eb/BBb bass & percussionists. if you fancy a change for the New Year & are looking for a friendly band, then please get in touch.

Ian Holmes

BA (hons), PGDip (RCM), ARCM, ALCM
Conductor, piano accompanist and educator