*
banner

Report & Results: 2017 Scottish Championships: Fourth Section

96 years of waiting is over for Dysart Colliery as they finally claim a Scottish title and head to Cheltenham with Newmains & District

Dysart Colliery
  A delighted Dysart Colliery claimed a long overdue victory in the Fourth Section

There was a wonderful story of almost unlimited contest patience and dedication that unfolded in the Fourth Section on Sunday morning in Perth, as thirteen bands provided excellent entertainment on Alan Fernie's 'St Andrew's Variations' set-work.

It culminated, after a remarkable period of 96 years of trying, with Dysart Colliery Band directed by Ross Brotherston, claiming their first Scottish Championship title — and in the process securing their place at the National Finals for the first time too. They will be joined there by Newmains & District.

Last win

The Scottish Championship was for many decades a totally separate contest (and in a way it remains so today), with the first event taking place in 1895. Dysart last tasted success in 1921 in the then Third Section — the year in which car tax was first introduced, Ernest Shackleton set sail for his last trip to Antarctica and the first Poppy Day was held.

No wonder their players didn't quite know how to celebrate victory.

Wonderful to see

It was simply wonderful to see, with tearful supporters and players (both very young and slightly older!) all taking it in turns to lift the trophy that ended perhaps one of the longest ever runs of unsuccessful competitive endeavour (with just a ten year break when they battled to even survive) in banding history.

And no wonder Band Secretary Ian McAlpine was still in a state of utter bewilderment when he spoke to 4BR: "It's beyond words how we feel at the moment,"he finally managed to say.

"We've been through some difficult times and went through a long period where we weren't able to compete: Our numbers dwindled, but we kept going.

We owe so much to so many dedicated people such as the late Bruce Fraser who helped us back. I'm sure many of us will be raising a glass or two to him in the days ahead".

Aims and objectives

Ian also acknowledged the contribution of many others, including his own daughters who played in the band, including the 'Best Instrumentalist' award winner Fiona Dick who has been a member for the past 25 years.

"We sat down last year and put plans in place that we wanted to have as our aims and objectives — with this weekend just the start.

Our conductor Ross Brotherston is doing a superb job, and we are fortunate to have players with Championship and First Section experience who have added so much to the band. We are now ahead of schedule, so all we can now do is plan for Cheltenham."

Non-competitive trio

Before the historic announcement, the audience had enjoyed a trio of performances from the non-competitive ensembles of the Section 4B class, who received critiques to help them in their further development by adjudicator Lynda Nicholson.

The Fourth Section judges, Dr Brett Baker and Sheona White then spoke of the enjoyable time they had in listening to the competitors, with Sheona also enjoying a bit of banter with her former teacher, John Boax, as she spoke of her pride on being able to return to adjudicate at a contest that held many happy memories for her.

The bands that had displayed musical style, contrasts in dynamics, good tuning and balance had featured in the prizes she said as she congratulated all the competitors for their fine efforts, although also pinpointing some concerns with what she playfully called 'over-enthusiastic' accompaniment.

No problems

No such problems though for the splendidly confident Dysart and to a lesser extent the neatly managed Newmains & District under Michael Marzella, who used all his years of experience to help steer his band to their first National Finals appearance.

Just behind them came a host of spirited performances led by third placed Bon Accord B directed by Jennifer Cook, with the remaining top-six places claimed by Dundee Instrumental, Penicuik Silver and Dumfries Town on a day that will live long in the memory for all the right contesting reasons.

It is said that success comes to those that wait — so after 96 years of trying, no one could begrudge Dysart Colliery their wonderful moment of victory celebration.

We've been through some difficult times and went through a long period where we weren't able to compete: Our numbers dwindled, but we kept goingBand Secretary Ian McAlpine

Results:

Fourth Section:


Test Piece: 'St Andrews Variations' (Alan Fernie)
Adjudicators: Dr Brett Baker and Sheona White

1. Dysart Colliery (Ross Brotherston) — 180*
2. Newmains & District (Michael Marzella) — 179*
3. Bon-Accord Silver B (Jennifer Cook) — 178
4. Dundee Instrumental (Robert McDonald) — 176
5. Penicuik Silver (Stuart Black) — 174
6. Dumfries Town (John Taylor) — 173
7. Newland Concert Brass (Paul McKelvie OBE) — 172
8. Kilmarnock Concert (Scott Walker) — 171
9. Highland Brass (Mark Bell) — 170
10. Stranraer Brass (Yvonne Williamson) — 168
11. Hawick Saxhorn (David Robb) — 167
12. Forfar Instrumental (Terrence Jackson) — 166
13. Queensferry Community Brass (James Anderson) — 164

*Top two bands qualify for National Final at Cheltenham

Youngest BBb Player:
Best Instrumentalist: Fiona Dick (Horn) — Dysart Colliery

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    


bic

Make sure you book your best BIC seat in the house

November 11 • Your really don't want to miss out on the entertainment at Brass in Concert this year — even if you can't make it to Gateshead.


Peter Moore

Moore on Radio 3

November 11 • The acclaimed soloist can be heard performing Dani Howard's 'Trombone Concerto' on Radio 3 next week.


Youth Championships

Limited places remain for Youth Champs 2026

November 11 • There are not many places left to be filled for the 2026 National Youth Championships — so you had better be quick if you want to be a part of a great day of music making.


Perth Concert Hall

Big turn out for Scottish battles in Perth

November 11 • There will be domestic as well as cross border rivalry on show in Perth later this month for the Band Supplies Scottish Challenge, Besson Scottish Open and Creative Scotland Scottish Youth Championships.


Regent Hall Concerts - Five By 5 Trumpet Ensemble

Friday 14 November • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. WC1 2DJ W1C2DJ


Contest: 48th Brass in Concert

Saturday 15 November • The Gladhous International Centre for Music, St Mary's Square, Gateshead NE8 2JR


Delph Band - Delph Youth Band

Sunday 16 November • Denshaw Village Hall, . Ripponden Rd, . Denshaw, . Oldham OL3 5SY


Regent Hall Concerts - Trombonanza with Brett Baker and Friends

Saturday 22 November • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. WC1 2DJ W1C2DJ


Dobcross Silver Band - Dobross Youth Band and Dobcross Brass Monkeys

Saturday 22 November • Civic Hall . Lee Street . Uppermill . Saddleworth OL3 6AE


Summerbridge & Dacre Silver Band

November 11 • Urgent:- Confident Solo Horn required to lead our horn section for our Christmas Concert and beyond. In the new year will be doing a joint concert with Carlton Main Frickley Colliery Band, and other concerts throughout the year.


Audley Brass

November 10 • Audley Brass (First Section National Finalists 2025) are seeking an Eb BASS PLAYER as we work towards our Dickens A Christmas Carol theme concert, the Beartown Brewery Christmas party and the 2026 Area contest.


Tintwistle Band

November 9 • Attention soprano cornet players!. Tintwistle band (famed for the number 1 hit single Matchstalk Men and Matchstalk Cats and Dogs!) are looking for a soprano cornet player!. We are 2nd section, enjoy all year round concerts/contests, and band social events.


Ian Holmes

BA (hons), PGDip (RCM), ARCM, ALCM
Conductor, piano accompanist and educator


               

 © 2025 4barsrest.com Ltd