Report & Results: 2017 Brass in Concert Championship

Eikanger claim a historic 'Grand Slam' and reveal the ambition to claim even more success after winning the Brass in Concert title in a style a bit like the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra...

Brass in Concert
  Eikanger celebrate after claiming the Brass in Concert title

Eikanger Bjorsvik flew home to Bergen on Monday afternoon having to juggle their luggage allowance at Newcastle airport to accommodate the extra silverware that came with being crowned 2017 Brass in Concert champion.

However, the Norwegians wouldn't have complained if their tickets were stamped with another extra addition, as victory at Sage Gateshead over the strongest field ever assembled for the event undoubtedly confirmed their status as the best brass band in the world.

Grand Slam

They end 2017 as European, Norwegian National, Siddis Entertainment and Brass in Concert title holders — a magnificent 'Grand Slam' of all the major championships they took part in. All that remains is the British Open, and that is very much on the radar in 2018. You wonder who could possibly stop them.

"We are thrilled,"spokesperson Viggo Borge told 4BR as they waited to board their plane back to Flesland airport.

"To be able to compete here is something we aimed to achieve by winning the Siddis title. Now we've become champions we look forward to returning again, although with the Europeans in Utrecht and British Open in Birmingham, we are finding out that being successful is also very expensive!"

Loose change

However, with £4,000 for claiming the Yamaha Newsome Trophy and another £1,000 for 'Quality of Performance', there should still have been enough loose change left in the band funds (plus a concert fee on the Saturday) to have been able to buy a few bottles of duty free champagne to celebrate with when they touched down.

"To win against such fantastic bands is a reason to celebrate,"Viggo added, before admitting, "...although we did a fair bit on Sunday night at our meal together in the hotel."

And as for the future?

"We enjoy competing against the very best in the world, and that's given us an extra incentive to qualify for the Europeans, Brass in Concert and British Open. We are still ambitious to do even better though, as we also want to become the officially ranked number 1 band in the world as well."

Shivers down spine

That aim will certainly send shivers of apprehension down the spines of domestic as well as international rivals, as the remarkable quality of their playing under conductor Reid Gilje brokered no argument; Jan Van der Roost and Lito Fontana awarding them first and second in terms of performance, with the other judges also placing them close to the top of their self-contained programme elements.

The specially commissioned 'Tales of the North Sea' set (premiered at Siddis just a fortnight ago) was a sumptuous musical canvas on which to display their outstanding talents (aided by the Mariana Trench deep sonority of 'Best Trombone' Tore Byrne Berg on bass trombone).

The concept was also a triumph; stimulating the musical mind as well as the emotional heart with its stylistic nuances full of rich textures, dry wit and ferocious drama. It was delivered with such a rare degree of musical artistry that the minimal amount choreography and multi-media presentation simply intensified the focus on their playing brilliance.

Berlin Philharmonic

Lito Fontana described it as 'AMAZING!!!' in summing up his written remarks, whilst Jan Van der Roost littered his with the adjectives, 'spectacular', 'terrific' and 'virtuoso'. Nick Grace described the programme content as demonstrating, 'progressive invention, creativity, inspiration'.

And whilst Peter Framcomb called their 'simple' entertainment and presentation 'engaging', Richard Evans compared the band to the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra with the degree of their 'incredible' professionalism. 'This band reminds me of them' he wrote.

Flotsam and jetsam

Not surprisingly then, behind Eikanger came rivals who gave of their all, but were still left bobbing in their wake like flotsam and jetsam.

They were led by Fountain City's bravura vibrancy, as the American's brilliantly energised, high-impact visual approach pinned the audience back in their seats from the word go.

Their runner-up finish, (adding the prizes for 'Programme Content', 'Best Performance in Entertainment & Presentation', 'Best Soprano' and 'Best Percussion') was not only testament to their audacious hutzpah (and solid playing), but also to the charismatic leadership of MD, Joseph Parisi, who has done so much to develop his ensemble into such a fine performance vehicle in all contesting disciplines.

Little wonder their Facebook page was packed full of congratulations from all parts of the USA and beyond. This could be the most significant contest result in American banding history — and a clarion call to reinvigorate a domestic banding movement (the US Open held on the same weekend had just five bands) that has been crying out for a worldwide standard bearer for the Stars & Stripes.

What now for UK bands

What the result means for UK banding will be a matter for a great deal of debate over the coming months — as the heavyweight trio of Foden's, Cory and Tredegar were bookended by Paris Brass Band in sixth.

Recently crowned National champion Brighouse & Rastrick ended seventh, with the rest (including a curiously subdued Grimethorpe) left to ponder how in future they can replicate the sense of innovative musical adventure displayed by the leading contenders. The dividing line between the best and rest was stark.

Foden's neatly realised 'Youth' programme certainly saw them back to their best under the baton of Dr Robert Childs, with euph star Gary Curtin claiming the prestigious 'Best Soloist' award for his terrific rendition of 'Elfriede'. Their entertainment approach sounded rejuvenated, the podium finish fully justified.

Cory tweaks

The result though may see Cory having to possibly consider tweaking elements of their hitherto all-conquering entertainment alchemy — although in terms of quality of performance (with deserved awards to Helen and Glyn Williams and tuba team) they were the equals of Eikanger.

Philip Harper's 'Sgt Pepper' inspiration was as clever and polished as ever, but also more than a touch familiar. Fourth place raised a few eyebrows for a number of different reasons.

So too the 'Breaking Boundaries' set from Tredegar. Ian Porthouse's team, aided by dancers from the Rambert Ballet took the BiC ethos of 'free from artistic restriction' at its inspirational word to claim the newly instigated 'Audience Prize' (as well as 'Best Baritone').

Their reputation for bold inventiveness and risk taking was displayed in full. Fifth place could have been higher.

With such a wide variety of approaches on show, it was certainly a day of subjective personal opinions, and not just with the judges. The esoteric Gallic delights of Paris Brass Band were chief amongst them.

French philosophy

Their philosophically inspired 'Life' programme, written by Fabien Cali certainly made the audience ponder, but like the writing of Jean Paul Sartre, it also took a fair bit of understanding (the explanatory narrative by Frank Renton almost sounding like the opening lines to a PhD lecture).

Ian Bousfield was impressed enough to award the composer the 'Best New Composition' prize, whilst sixth place overall was a fair indication of the French band's very particular qualities. Some people really loved it, others looked a touch puzzled.


There was debate too over Brighouse in seventh — with many listeners thoroughly engrossed by their contemporary 'human spirit' set under David Thornton, whilst others not as sure. All were agreed though on the luscious playing of Sheona White in taking the 'Best Horn' prize.

If there was a disappointing element to the day, it perhaps came with the 'tick box' approaches to Programme Content and Entertainment & Presentation of the bands in the minor placings: Not for the first time, the rather prescriptive use of the multi-media resources and choreography seemingly designed with in-built risk aversion, safety-first default settings.

A little more adventure and inventiveness would surely have benefited Carlton Main, Virtuosi GUS (both somewhat surprisingly failing to keep within the 23 minute time constraints), Grimethorpe, Flowers and Leyland, although each played to their obvious strengths (the superb Kirsty Abbotts winning a fifth 'Best Principal Cornet ' award) and predilections.

Artistic freedom

No such complaints could be geared at the Brass in Concert organisers though.

Whilst the marking system still needs modification if it is to truly reflect the 'artistic freedom' the contest aims to achieve, the willingness to engage with the competitors, the interactive audience vote, 'Ask Frank' and social media features were further signs of progressive moves in the right direction. All that and Sage Gateshead continues to provide the best brass band entertainers in the world with a platform worthy of their exceptional talents.

And none more so than Eikanger Bjorsvik.

Their Viking ancestors came to these shores just over a thousand years ago to make their mark before leaving for home with plenty of silverware to their name: Now, a millennium or more later they have retuned and done it all again.

Lito Fontana described it as 'AMAZING!!!' in summing up his written remarks, whilst Jan Van der Roost littered his with the adjectives, 'spectacular', 'terrific' and 'virtuoso'4BR



Jan Van der Roost & Lito Fontana (Music: Quality of Performance)
Nick Grace (Programme Content)
Richard Evans & Peter Francomb (Entertainment & Presentation)
Ian Bousfield (Soloist & Individual Awards)

Music/Music/Content/Entertainment = Total
Van der Roost/Fontana/Grace/Evans/Francomb= Total

1. Eikanger-Bjørsvik (Reid Gilje): (1) 60 / (2) 57 / (2) 38 / (3) 18 / (5) 16: 189pts
2. Fountain City (Joseph Parisi): (5) 48 / (4) 51 / (1) 40 / (1) 20 / (1) 20: 179pts
3. Foden's (Dr Robert Childs): (4) 51 / (3) 54 / (4) 34 / (2) 19 / (3) 18: 176pts
4. Cory (Philip Harper): (2) 57 / (1) 60 / (6) 30 / (5) 16 / (9) 12: 175pts
5. Tredegar (Ian Porthouse): (3) 54 / (5) 48 / (5) 32 / (4) 17 / (4) 17: 168pts
6. Paris Brass Band (Florent Didier): (6) 45 / (7) 42 / (3) 36 / (10) 11 / (8) 13: 147pts
7. Brighouse & Rastrick (Dr David Thornton): (7) 42 / (6) 45 / (7) 28 / (7) 14 / (7) 14: 143pts
8. Carlton Main Frickley (Ian McElligott): (9) 36 / (8) 39 / (9) 24 / (11) 10 / (11) 10: 117pts*
9. Virtuosi GUS (Adam Cooke): (8) 39 / (10) 33 / (8) 26 / (12) 9 / (6) 15: 116pts**
10. Grimethorpe Colliery (Cpt Sam Hairsine): (10) 33 / (9) 36 / (12) 18 / (6) 15 / (12) 9: 111pts
11. Flowers (David Childs): (12) 27 / (12) 27 / (10) 22 / (9) 12 / (2) 19: 107pts
12. Leyland (Thomas Wyss): (11) 30 / (11) 30 / (11) 20 / (8) 13 / (10) 11: 104pts

* 2pts deducted for time penalty
**6ts deducted for time penalty

Individual Awards:

Quality of Performance: Eikanger-Bjørsvik
Programme Content: Fountain City
Best Performance in Entertainment & Presentation: Fountain City
Audience Entertainment Trophy: Tredegar
Best New Composition: 'Life' by Fabien Cali (Paris Brass Band)
Best Soloist: Gary Curtin (euphonium) — Foden's
Best Soprano: Ryan Sharp (Fountain City)
Best Principal Cornet: Kirsty Abbotts (Carlton Main Frickley Colliery)
Best Flugel: Helen Williams (Cory)
Best Tenor Horn: Sheona White (Brighouse & Rastrick)
Best Baritone: Ben Stratford (Tredegar)
Best Euphonium: Glyn Williams (Cory)
Best Trombone: Tore Bryne Berg (bass trombone) Eikanger-Bjørsvik
Best Bass Section: Cory
Best Percussion: Fountain City
Youngest Player: Alex Evans (Tredegar)

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    

Wallace Mute

4BR Shop: Wallace Bb cornet practice mute

December 6 • A special 4BR Shop/Band Supplies deal for Christmas..


4BR Quiz: What trophy...?

December 6 • You will need to use your Christmas mince pies to identify this bit of festive gold to win a trio of new CD releases...


Cavanagh takes baritone role at Black Dyke

December 5 • Michael Cavanagh becomes the new solo baritone players at Black Dyke


Black Dyke awards to McGlynn and Smith

December 5 • Dave McGlynn and Dave Smith are presented with the 'Bandsman of the Year' and 'Pondasher' awards at Black Dyke's annual presentation evening.

Black Dyke Band - Huddersfield Choral Society

Friday 6 December • Huddersfield Town Hall, Corporation Street, Huddersfield HD1 2TA

St Albans City Band - Nextstage Community Choir

Friday 6 December • Homewood Road URC Church , Sandpit Lane, St Albans AL1 3RD

Regent Hall Concerts - Royal Greenwich Brass Band presents "Christmas wit

Friday 6 December • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street Opp. RESERVED. London . W1C 2DJ

London Metropolitan Brass - Annual Charity Christmas Concert

Saturday 7 December • East Finchley Methodist Church, 205B High Rd, Finchley, London N2 8AN

The Fairey Band - Dobross Youth Band

Saturday 7 December • Civic Hall/Lee St, Oldham OL3 6AE OL3 6AE

Greenfield Band

December 6 • We require a Bb Bass player & kit percussionist to join our busy 2nd Section (North West) band immediately for Butlins and Area contests and beyond under the guidance of our new MD Phil Goodwin. Rehearsals Monday & Thursday 8-10pm in Saddleworth.

Wakefield Metropolitan Brass Band

December 5 • Solo Horn and Flugelhorn/Cornet required to complete the line up for the areas next year. A friendly band with a sensible engagement list and can arrange transport from Wakefield stations. Rehearsals Monday and Thursday 7:45-9:30

Longridge Band

December 5 • The Longridge Band (First Section North West) currently requires a percussionist.. . The band is one of the most well organised and run bands in the area, with a good mixture of contests/concerts and social activities planned for 2020.

Sandy Smith

Conductor, teacher, adjudicator and arranger


 © 2019 4barsrest.com Ltd